Stopping a Toxic Relationship: The Truth About Change
About the Guest
Are all conflicts created equal? Not necessarily, especially if you're in a toxic relationship, according to Christian counselor Leslie Vernick. Leslie talks about changing an emotionally destructive relationship into a healthy one, beginning with your own behavior and response.
Leslie VernickLeslie Vernick is a licensed counselor and coach with over 30 years experience helping individuals and couples. Leslie gently leads her clients and connections to: *Discover the courage to deal with destructive relationships Heal from a negative self-image or poor self-esteem *Confidently speak thoughts and feelings in a constructive way Encounter God’s peace in the midst of suffering or difficult loss *Develop the discipline to turn dreams and desires into realities She and her husba...more
Leslie Vernick talks about changing an emotionally destructive relationship into a healthy one, beginning with your own behavior and response.
Stopping a Toxic Relationship: The Truth About Change
Bob: Before we dig in and talk about how we turn the tide, how we navigate change in an emotionally destructive relationship; is it even important whether we identify the level of destruction that’s taking place? I talked about this kind of garden variety sinful pattern. I mean, I’ve said things to my wife that I wish I hadn’t said, that have been hurtful, or harmful. She’s said things to me that she wishes she hadn’t said. I wouldn’t say we’re in an emotionally destructive relationship. Is it important to hang a label on that or do we just recognize that wherever we are, we want to get better?
Leslie: Well, I think that’s part of the key, is to recognize that both of you recognize that you’ve said things that are harmful to each other. James tells us in James 3:2, “We all stumble in many ways.” So we aren’t going to live with perfect people, and we’re going to live with people who are broken just like us and say bad things.
But a healthy person, when they recognize that they’ve sinned against another person, because they see that person’s hurt or because that person has said, “You hurt me,” they own it. They take responsibility for it and they work at changing it. An unhealthy person won’t see it, they will blame you for it, they won’t take any responsibility for it and they repeat it over and over again.
The difference between a healthy relationship or a destructive relationship, or a difficult relationship, is one of safety. I think when you feel safe enough to say “Ouch!” to somebody, “That really hurt me.” And the other person says, “You know, I shouldn’t have said that. I was tired or I lost my temper; I need to get better control of my temper, my words, or whatever,” then you can move on.
But when someone doesn’t feel even safe enough to tell someone, “That really hurt me” or “That really bothers me,” they can’t express their opinion. They can’t be who they are because who they are is unacceptable to the other person. Then it becomes a real destructive relationship.
Bob: We were chuckling, just for a minute, before we came on the air here about the fact that your mother called you a “nincompoop” when you were growing up. [Laughter] Repeatedly right?
Dennis: Oh, yes; I was just reflecting. She could have probably done it in a little more respectful manner, but I knew my mom loved me. My mom and I had a great relationship and it was more of an affectionate term that was saying, “Son, straighten up.”
Bob: You didn’t walk away going, “Ouch,” or you didn’t walk away thinking, “I really am stupid,” did you?
Dennis: No; again, I don’t think so. I mean, as much as I can tell today.
Bob: Leslie, here’s my question in all of this.
Dennis: A few years have passed since then, you know. [Laughter] It’s like we all carry these little words with us that were said to us by our parents, and some of the statements they made.
Bob: Is it possible that in some relationships there’s playful banter that takes place that in another relationship the same kind of pattern would be abusive but in this one it’s not?
Leslie: Absolutely, as long as both people are in agreement of it. If both people are okay with it, and it’s not hurting anybody and they’re getting something out of their system and they’re fighting and they can manage that without either one of them feeling like they’re scared or they can’t take it or they’re falling apart or it inhibits their growth or that damages them, then it’s okay. I think everybody’s pain threshold is different, whether it’s for physical pain, or relational pain, or emotional pain.
I remember, when I had my first child, we were into Lamaze. I was going to have this natural childbirth. All my friends were telling me, “You know, it’s a piece of cake; you can do it,” and I couldn’t. I couldn’t do it. Ten hours later I was saying, “Give me drugs! I want drugs now!” [Laughter]
I felt like such a failure because, for whatever reason, my pain threshold was lower, or I was more sensitive or it hurt me more, or maybe they could take it longer.
I think we do an injustice and we’re very unfair to some people when maybe we could take that, and they can’t. So we’re saying, “You’re just too sensitive,” but if they’re married to someone who is treating them that way, part of loving that person is to know that they’re sensitive.
Bob: There’s part of me, as we talk about this, I’m just a little concerned that some folks are going to go, “You know maybe I am in an emotionally destructive relationship. I thought I was okay until today. But maybe it is emotionally destructive.” And what we’ve really done is made them more sensitive to something that they didn’t need to be sensitive to. Does that make sense?
Leslie: I hear you and I think that’s a possibility. If someone is looking to be a victim, they can find it; but there are times when cancer is growing and you don’t know it’s there, so we do need to define what it means. I think by taking the test, that you’re offering on your website, people will have a clear idea: is it just small potatoes or is this something that I’ve felt for a long time and now I have a word to describe it?
Bob: The test you’re talking about is from your book, The Emotionally Destructive Relationship. Thirty one questions that help somebody evaluate just how bad is this?
It’s on our website at FamilyLifeToday.com if our listeners are interested in going there. This would be a helpful diagnostic tool for them.
Dennis: It would be good. I found it interesting, Leslie, in your book that you have an entire section that is explaining biblical authority of headship and submission. Now, I’ve got a sneaking suspicion that you have seen, as a counselor, a number of situations where men have overused their authority and where women have given men too much authority.
Leslie: I have, unfortunately, and I think some churches endorse that. I really wanted to be biblical in this book because I speak with so many women and men who are in destructive relationships and they try to go to the place that should give them the most help, which is the church. And they’ve been misled, they’ve been hurt more, they’ve been told, “Well, that’s just how it is. God put him in charge, so you just have to obey and submit.”
Even if he’s steering the whole family right off the edge of a cliff, you’re not allowed to say “no;” you’re not allowed to jump ship; you’re not allowed to do anything but go over, and the whole kids and family and everybody goes over the cliff.
Dennis: We did a series of broadcasts here on FamilyLife Today a number of years ago - Bob’s going to know exactly the ones I’m talking about. We had a counselor from Southern California, and a deputy sheriff from Milwaukee, Wisconsin. We talked about abusive relationships where there was…
Bob: . . .where there was domestic violence.
Dennis: . . . domestic violence. You’ll not be surprised at what they said in that interview. They said that the place that fostered the most of this were extreme fundamentalist churches.
Leslie: I have seen a number of situations like that. I could go story after story after story, so that’s why I felt it was so important for me to clarify all these things with biblical terms, because I want people who are strong believers, who are committed Christians, who are godly people who want to do what God wants them to do, [to know] that God has a plan for them, and he has a way for them to deal with this in a biblical way.
Headship - I just want to define this really clearly - is not just getting your own way, which is oftentimes what men who claim headship scripture passages. “This means I get to make all the decisions. This means I get to do what I want to do and you have no right to contradict that.” That’s not what headship is biblically. Headship is a loving sacrificial service of the other person, and you get to do that first as the head.
Submission is never something you can make someone do. Submission, godly submission, is done by the person who is doing the submitting and they do it willingly. So as soon as someone forces someone to submit, it’s not biblical submission. It’s called coercion, manipulation, force, or rape sometimes; so it’s not those terms.
Bob: Yes, I have to tell you a story. I think I’ve shared this on FamilyLife Today, but I’ll never forget it. I was driving along with a friend of mine; he was in his first year of marriage. I just said, “How are things going with you and Cathy?” He said, “Oh, we’re doing all right.” He said, “She’s just not really submitting to me the way she ought to.”
I said, “Well, that’s interesting. What makes you think she’s supposed to?” He looked at me like, “Well, you know the Bible. You’ve read the Bible.” I said, “Yes, there’s one in the glove compartment. Get it out.”
So he got it out and turned to Ephesians chapter five and I said, “So, what does it say there?” He said, “Right here, it says ‘Wives submit…’” I said, “Stop. What’s the first word there?” “Wives.” I said, “Are you a wife?” He said, “No.” I said, “OK, move on, that verse isn’t for you then. You go onto the one that says ‘husbands’ and read that part.”
My point – and he laughed, he knew what I was trying to say - my point is it’s not your job, if you’re a wife, to get your husband to lead or, if you’re a husband, to get your wife to submit. It’s your responsibility to do what God’s called you to do.
Dennis: Yes, and Leslie, let’s say right now, there is a woman who is listening to this broadcast and she’s, all of a sudden, moved very close to the radio, or to her iPod or her computer.
She’s going, “I think I’m in a relationship where I’m being abused by a husband who is overreaching his authority and he’s abusing me with it.” How do you stop that?
Leslie: Well, the beginning of change in a destructive relationship starts with you. You have to begin to identify and own your problem. You might say, “Well, that’s not my problem that he’s acting that way.” But when you’re a repeated victim of someone, you have to begin to ask yourself what’s your part? It might just be that you’re not educated or you’re too passive, or you’ve believed the wrong things but there’s something about that that’s kept you in that destructive dance (you’re afraid). So, when you begin to identify your part, then you can begin to make a change because you can’t change another person, you can only start by changing yourself.
Dennis: You know, I want to speak to that for a second because I’m thinking of a relationship that I endured for the better part of two decades. What you just described was me. Now, here I am, I know the Bible. I’ve written books about relationships, I teach about relationships.
I was in a relationship - not a close one that was like my wife or my children, or immediate family - but I was in a relationship that was not healthy. I really did keep on allowing that to occur, so I’ve been there. It’s interesting how we can continue to walk into this thing and be abused over and over and over again. It’s almost like sheep to the slaughter.
Bob: You tell the story in your book about a woman you identify as “Cynthia” who came to you who was at this end point in her relationship with her husband and you had to coach her through how to stop it, right?
Leslie: I had to coach her through how to stop it and she represents so many other women that I talk with. She wanted to come to counseling for me to somehow give her some magic bullet that would help her to change her husband. I had to help her to understand that I didn’t have that magic bullet; all I could do was help her to stop herself from putting up with this kind of relationship. She was afraid to do that.
But she couldn’t begin to change it until she was willing to look at herself first.
Bob: What was going on in her relationship with her husband?
Leslie: Well, her husband was continually deceitful; he had committed a number of affairs. He had no real remorse for them. He was indifferent to their relationship; she had to do all the work, all the care of the children, manage all the finances, and he kind of just lived as a single person but with the perks of married life.
Bob: So she comes and says, “How do I fix this? How do I fix him?”
Leslie: “God wants us to have a good relationship, and I know that God hates divorce, and I really want this marriage to work. How can I get him to change and how can I get him to tell the truth and how can I get him to love me?” All the kind of things that every woman longs for, but you can’t make someone love you. You can’t make someone be honest. You can’t make someone change.
Bob: So what did you tell her to do?
Leslie: So I told her “Cynthia, change begins with you, so the question you need to begin to ask yourself is, ‘Why are you willing to live with a man who treats you this way?’” And she said, “I don’t know? Because I think God wants me to. I’m supposed to stay here.”
It was very difficult for her to begin to look at what her part of it was because loving someone isn’t just allowing them to continue to sin against you with no protest. Loving them well, biblically, means that you begin to speak the truth in love into their life.
Dennis: Yes, and it’s interesting as we look at the Bible, we know we’re commanded to love our enemies. I think sometimes, and this is what happened in my twenty-year-long relationship, I was doing my best to model to this other person what Christian love was all about. But as it became clear that I was being manipulated, taken advantage of, and really abused, I realized that there was a time that I had to draw a line in the sand and say, “No more. You’re not going to do that to me anymore.”
Bob: You’re saying to the other person, “I’m not going to let you do this because it’s not right for you, as well as being hurtful to me. It’s not loving to you to let you continue in that pattern.”
Dennis: Right, and the key thing was, I had a choice to be able to draw that line in the sand, and then I had to, as you said earlier, Bob, “buck up.” I had to stand up and be courageous to stick to it, and not keep walking into an abusive situation to be take advantage of. In my situation, the way I handled it, was I took a friend with me. I took a partner who went with me into the relationship and in the process helped me stay on the right side of the line in the sand.
Leslie: I think it would be really helpful right now to talk about what is a healthy relationship. The difference between a healthy relationship or a destructive relationship is one in which there’s mutual caring, mutual honesty, and mutual respect.
If we just talk about respect, one of the things that I’ve found in a relationship that’s been destructive in my life is that this person, whenever I say “no,” there’s this manipulative guilt that comes in. There’s these boundary pushings.
I’m not allowed to say no. I’m not allowed to have boundaries or I’m a bad person.
Leslie: So it doesn’t lend to a healthy relationship. The operative word here in mutual caring, mutual honesty, and mutual respect is “mutual.” So, we can have ministry to certain people, who may have needs and God calls us to minister to our enemies. But don’t confuse that with healthy relationship, and that’s what you began to say, “I can’t have a healthy relationship with this person. I may be able to minister to them here and there, but I can’t have this relationship.”
Dennis: I think what you just summarized there is very important because that was the conclusion I came to. Number one, I was kidding myself to think I could have healthy relationship with someone where there couldn’t be any mutual love and respect.
Dennis: It wasn’t happening.
Leslie: They wanted you to care for them but they weren’t caring for you, right?
Dennis: Exactly; but, secondly, I had to come to the conclusion that I couldn’t have a relationship at all. Now, it’s one thing, Leslie, if the person I’m relating to is miles away and I’m not in marriage with them. . .
. . . but speak to the person right now who’s married to the person who, first they realize they can’t have a healthy relationship and secondly they’re not even sure they can achieve a real relationship with them.
Leslie: That is the dilemma and you can make a marriage better all by yourself. You cannot make a marriage work or a marriage good all by yourself. It takes mutual effort, mutual caring, mutual honesty, and mutual respect. So, I think sometimes the burden of making a marriage good has been put on someone’s shoulders as their sole responsibility and they’ve taken it, and it’s not possible.
I think one of the things we need to do is just help people understand what it takes to have a good healthy relationship. If someone is in that situation though, especially in a marriage, what I coach them to do is, if they begin to get healthier, then they can begin to invite their partner into healthy change; because, when you’re in a marriage, you’re sort of like dancing with somebody. When you’re dancing with someone, and it’s fine with them that they’re stepping on your toes, and they’re kicking you in the shins, but it’s not fine with you, you need to begin to speak up and say, “You know, this hurts me, I don’t like this.”
And, oftentimes, if you’ve never done that before, and you’ve been in a destructive relationship, if the other person cares about you, they will begin to hear you. Sometimes they don’t, and you need to up the ante. That’s when you begin to stand up and say, “I can’t allow myself to be treated this way anymore.”
Dennis: You know, it’s really interesting, I’ve now lived enough life that I still have a lot of idealism, but it’s been edited by reality.
Leslie: Yes, me too.
Dennis: Relationships are probably the number one editor of reality in my life. It doesn’t mean we should lose our hope, and it doesn’t mean we should revert to fleshly ways of dealing with relationships. In fact, as you were talking, I was thinking about a passage in Romans 12 that says, “Never be conceited, repay no one evil for evil.”
“But give thought to do what is honorable in the sight of all.” Then it adds something that you alluded to a little earlier. It says, “If possible, so far as it depends on you, live peaceably with all.” It goes on to say, “Beloved, never avenge yourselves; leave room for the wrath of God.”
I think sometimes we lose sight of who God is in these relationships. It may be, at points, that we need to take a step back and pray for the person who is abusing us and pray that God will - not necessarily get even, but - get his attention, or get her attention, and begin to take a step back and get healthy in your relationship with that other person; because, if you don’t, you’re going to keep on walking in there as I described how I did for 20 years. You’re going to keep on getting hurt. You’re going to leave that relationship going, “Man, how can I do a better job of loving? How can I help this person come to a faith in Christ?”
It’s not all dependent upon you.
Bob: Well, and as we’ve said here, it’s in part about getting help for yourself, for your own physical or emotional safety. But it’s also about, “How can I boldly love another person?”
Bob: Sometimes the boldest way to love is to say, “No; no more.”
Dennis: Is to bow up and look them in the eye, or write a letter, or draw that line in the sand, and say, “You know what? That kind of treatment of me is not going to happen.”
Bob: Yes. That’s what the Bible means when it talks about loving confrontation: speaking the truth in love to another person. That’s what it ought to look like and, Leslie, you outline for folks in your book, The Emotionally Destructive Relationship: Seeing it, Stopping it, and Surviving it, how to confront people like that.We’ve got copies of the book in our FamilyLife Today Resource Center.
I want to encourage our listeners: if what you’ve heard today sounds familiar, go to our website, FamilyLifeToday.com. Click in the upper left-hand corner of the screen where it says, “Go Deeper,” and you’ll find information there about Leslie Vernick’s book, The Emotionally Destructive Relationship. You can order from us online at FamilyLifeToday.com, or you can call 1-800-FLTODAY; 1-800-358-6329. Order a copy of the book by calling 1-800 F as in “family,” L as in “life,” and then the word “TODAY.”
You know, one of the foundations for any kind of healthy relationship is that we renew our minds, that we think as God has taught us to think; we think with the mind of Christ. That’s why it’s so important for couples to be on the same page and to be pursuing oneness; to be asking, “What would God have us do in our relationship?”
“How can we honor Him – glorify Him? How can we be of one mind? How can we be united as husband and wife?” FamilyLife has a tool to help couples with that. It’s called the FamilyLife Bible for Couples. This is something we’ve put together so that a husband and wife can go through it together, or you can do it in a small group setting. This week, we’re making this Bible study for couples available to anyone who can help support the ministry with a donation.
We are at the midway point of 2014 and a mid-year donation to FamilyLife Today would be particularly helpful. This is a time of year when we often hear from fewer listeners than normal, so if you can go online or call us or write a check and mail it to us today, that would be very helpful. Go to FamilyLifeToday.com; click in the upper right-hand corner of the screen where it says, “I CARE,” to make an online donation. Or call 1-800-FLTODAY; you can make your donation over the phone and request the Bible study for couples when you do.
Or you can write a check and mail it to FamilyLife Today along with your request for the Bible study. Our mailing address is Post Office Box 7111, Little Rock, Arkansas; our zip code is 72223.
Now, tomorrow we want to talk about how you maintain a sense of your own sanity in the midst of an emotionally challenging relationship. Leslie Vernick’s going to be back with us again tomorrow; I hope you can be back with us as well.
I want to thank our engineer today, Keith Lynch, along with our entire broadcast production team. On behalf of our host, Dennis Rainey, I'm Bob Lepine. We will see you back next time for another edition of FamilyLife Today.
FamilyLife Today is a production of FamilyLife of Little Rock, Arkansas.
Help for today. Hope for tomorrow.
We are so happy to provide these transcripts to you. However, there is a cost to produce them for our website. If you’ve benefited from the broadcast transcripts, would you consider donating today to help defray the costs?
Copyright © 2014 FamilyLife. All rights reserved.